Your home is among your most valuable possessions, so you ought to protect it with homeowners insurance. Choosing among the many insurance providers can feel like an overwhelming task, but if you focus on the best home insurance companies, you can make things a lot easier for yourself. Here are some of our favorite home insurance providers for several common scenarios.
Pros
Cons
Erie Insurance customers who bundle home and auto insurance could save up to 25% on their premiums. That's a tempting reason to consider it, but it's not the only one. Customers can also look forward to strong customer satisfaction ratings and guaranteed replacement cost coverage included at no additional cost. They also offer coverage for pets, gift card and gift certificate reimbursement, and hard-to-replace items. This coverage is included in all policies at no additional cost. Erie's base policy offers more flexibility and coverage options than many competitors.
Pros
Cons
National Average = $1,569
States with Lowest Annual Premiums:
Allstate offers some of the most generous discounts in the industry, which includes a discount up to 25% when you bundle home and auto policies, up to 20% when you switch to Allstate without a recent home insurance claim, 10% loyalty discount, and 5% automatic payment. Allstate also has an extensive network of agents.
Pros
Cons
National Average = $1,863
States with Lowest Annual Premiums:
Amica isn't as well known as some of the other home insurance companies on this list, but if you asked its customers about their experiences, most would probably give you glowing reviews. Amica Mutual ranks highest in J.D. Power's homeowners insurance segment for a second consecutive year. While its coverage options may not be as extensive as some of its competitors, it does the basics extremely well, and you won't find an equal to its dividend policies anywhere else. In addition, Amica has teamed up with Rocket Mortgage, and Amica policyholders can receive special loan pricing and save $2,000 on closing costs.
Pros
Cons
National Average = $3,022
States with Lowest Annual Premiums:
State Farm notes on its website that you can save up to $1,127 on auto and home insurance. If you have an auto insurance policy, State Farm notes that you can add a homeowners, renters, condo, or life insurance policy and save up to 17% on home insurance premiums. State Farm offers customizable homeowners policies that include optional coverage for pets, identity theft, and water backup.
Pros
Cons
National Average = $1,726
States with Lowest Annual Premiums:
Lemonade is a top destination for customers looking for cheap home insurance, with premiums starting as low as $25 per month. The company makes shopping for insurance easy by offering an all-online application process and instant answers. Policies can be managed primarily through the Lemonade app or online.
Pros
Cons
While Travelers has a lot of great coverage options that appeal to a broad base of homeowners, it's especially popular with those interested in green homes and sustainable living. Not only does it offer green home coverage to help homeowners rebuild their home with greener materials, but it also rewards green homeowners with a sweet discount on their premiums. For example, you can save up to 5% if your home is certified a "green home" by the Leadership Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) organization.
Pros
Cons
National Average = $4,824
States with Lowest Annual Premiums:
USAA is the go-to home insurance provider for just about everyone who qualifies for it. Unfortunately, it's only available to military members, veterans, and their families. Homeowners who fall into one of these groups should definitely give it a look as it's often one of the most affordable home insurance companies around, and its customer satisfaction ratings are the highest in the industry. USAA would be ranked #1 in virtually all areas of the U.S. in J.D. Power rankings, but because it doesn't meet its award criteria, J.D. Power gives USAA a score but does not include it in the rankings
Pros
Cons
National Average = $1,770
States with Lowest Annual Premiums:
Homeowners insurance is a type of insurance policy that protects the policyholder's home and personal property against storm damage, theft, vandalism, and other hazards. It can also help homeowners pay to stay somewhere else if they're forced to vacate their current home.
However, a typical homeowners insurance policy doesn't protect homeowners against everything. Flood and earthquake damage are typically excluded. Those interested in these types of coverage must purchase a separate flood or earthquake insurance policy.
Homeowners who have mortgages often have to deal with homeowners insurance lender requirements. This is where lenders require homeowners to purchase insurance to ensure it will still get paid even if the home is destroyed in a natural disaster.
Those who own their home outright aren't required to purchase homeowners insurance, but it's a good idea to have coverage anyway. Without homeowners insurance, you must pay for any damage to your home on your own, and this could easily cost tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars.Types of protections
Homeowners must get the right kinds of protections so they can transfer an appropriate amount of risk to an insurer. Specifically, it is important for a homeowner to have:Policy limits
Homeowners also must consider their policy limits. This is the maximum amount the insurer will pay when a covered loss occurs. If a property has replacement value coverage with a policy limit of $400,000, the insurer would pay a maximum of $400,000 in damages if the home was damaged or destroyed.If the policy limits are too low, a homeowner may face uncompensated losses. This is a major concern especially with liability insurance as a victim could sue a homeowner personally to recover uncompensated damages above policy limits when serious injuries occur.Many insurers also require property owners to buy coverage with a policy limit equal to at least 80% of the replacement value of the home. So, someone with a $400,000 home would need a policy limit of $320,000 or higher. Otherwise, the insurer would not pay the full amount of damages in the event of a covered loss.Determining the replacement costs of a home can be complicated. Homeowners may be able to calculate this on their own if they know the square footage of their home and the rough cost of construction per square foot in their area. Online home value calculators or professional appraisers can also help homeowners determine how much home insurance coverage they need.Offer | Best For | Next Steps |
---|---|---|
![]()
Liberty Mutual
|
Great For: Best for optional coverages | |
![]()
Erie Homeowners Insurance
|
Great For: Best for flexible policies | |
![]()
Allstate
|
Great For: Best for generous discounts | |
![]()
Amica
|
Great For: Best for customer service | |
![]()
State Farm
|
Great For: Best for bundling policies | |
![]()
Lemonade
|
Great For: Best for tech-savvy shoppers | |
![]()
Travelers
|
Great For: Best for green homes | |
![]()
USAA
|
Great For: Best for military members and their families |
Dr. Patrick van Esch
Assistant Professor of Marketing, Kennesaw State UniversityHow do you think climate change will impact homeowners insurance?
With droughts, fires, floods, and sea-levels on the rise, so too will insurance premiums. Insurance firms continue to assess the risk profile of consumers, the economy, and the environment in relation to the products they offer. With inevitable increases in homeowners insurance premiums, consumers may be forced to pay higher prices for plans that actually provide less in terms of coverage. Worse still, consumers may even be dropped by their insurer. Remembering that insurance is state-regulated (for example, the Federal Insurance Office or the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act), if consumers experience such challenging circumstances, they can contact their state’s department of insurance to find out if their insurance provider is breaking the law.What can homeowners concerned with weather threats do to make sure they’re covered?
If buying a house, always consider the location and check if it is part of a fire, flood, or extreme weather zone. If you already own a home in a high-risk area, look for ways to reduce your risk and expenses. For example, look for opportunities to weatherproof your future or existing home. Moreover, when selecting an appropriate insurance policy, look for an insurer that gives pricing discounts for adding weatherproofing. Lastly, many financial factors determine the price of insurance policies, so it's important to build and maintain a good credit score.What should homeowners do if their policy is canceled as the result of a weather emergency?
Don’t give up! Contact the insurance provider and seek advice on what you might be able to change for them to insure you again. If that fails, shop around as there are many mainstream and independent insurers offering different types of policies at a range of different prices. Additionally, talk to family and friends and ask which insurer they use, as those firms already have a precedence of insuring houses in your particular location. Lastly, if you can’t get an insurance firm to provide you cover, reach out to your state department. They may be able to offer a Fair Access to Insurance Requirements (FAIR) Plan. But remember, these types of plans only cover the bare-minimum.Prachi Gala
Assistant Professor of Marketing at Coles College of Business at Kennesaw State UniversityHow do you think climate change will impact homeowners insurance?
We have already noticed a lot of weather reactions resulting from climate change. These weather changes come in the form of more tornadoes, flooding, and fires, among many others.There are at least two ways that climate change will affect homeowners insurance:What can homeowners concerned with weather threats do to make sure they’re covered?
Customers can always ask for additional coverage. For example, your home insurance company may suggest that you don’t need the flood coverage, as you are not in a flood prone area. In that scenario, you can ask them to cover you, for an additional cost, if you think that climate change could make your area flood prone. Depending on where you live and your insurance company, things that are usually not covered include:What should homeowners do if their policy is canceled as the result of a weather emergency?
Tim Zhang
Finance Professor at University of WyomingHow do you think climate change will impact homeowners insurance?
With the increasing impact of climate change, U.S. homeowners have already started to see multi-faceted changes to their home insurance. For example, more extreme weather is causing insurance premiums to rise. But in places that are more vulnerable to extreme weather, residents have more extensive insurance options. However, weather emergencies started to visit unexpected places where insuring your properties used to seem unnecessary. In those areas with an extremely high risk of climate disaster, insurers have canceled home insurance policies to protect themselves, leaving local residents unprotected. In recent years, climate change has become more like a systematic risk factor, significantly affecting the rate and availability of homeowners insurance.What can homeowners concerned with weather threats do to make sure they’re covered?
Knowing what to expect from weather threats and when to expect them is a good starting point. As a homeowner, you need to know every detail of your policy -- since your insurance coverage can depend entirely on the policy you choose and what coverage is available in your state. For instance, many people with homeowners insurance are not aware that flood damage is not included in their coverage. Make sure you add any weather-related risk to your coverage from the start and plan ahead. Many companies will not allow you to add additional coverage within 30 days of a predicted weather event.What should homeowners do if their policy is canceled as the result of a weather emergency?
If your policy is canceled due to a weather emergency, your first step is to call your agent or carrier to find out why it is being terminated and see if you can convince them to keep your coverage. In some cases, you may be able to make changes to your home or policy, such as repairing a damaged roof, which will satisfy the insurance company. If you're not able to convince your agent, or you're having trouble finding another affordable home insurance, check with your state’s department of insurance. They may provide a list of carriers who are capable of providing coverage in your area. Do it as soon as you can, because your lender may purchase a new home insurance policy on your behalf and expect you to pay for it.Brian Adams
Associate Dean of Graduate Business Programs at University of Portland’s Pamplin School of BusinessHow do you think climate change will impact homeowners insurance?
U.S. insurance firms have already begun to assess the potential financial impact of climate risk exposure. Looking at this trend from a positive viewpoint, homeowners in areas of the country with a higher probability of loss from climate change should be protected from significant loss through their homeowners insurance. However, this added protection will likely come with higher premiums and with additional language in homeowners policies regarding climate risks and what is not covered by insurance.What can homeowners concerned with weather threats do to make sure they’re covered?
As with all financial services we purchase, it benefits the consumer to establish relationships with their brokers and agents at banks, insurance companies, real estate firms, and more. The better communication you can build with your financial institutions, the more likely you will be fully informed on the financial services you have purchased. It also helps you get your questions answered quickly.What should homeowners do if their policy is canceled as the result of a weather emergency?
It is difficult for a homeowner to have risk management options if their policy is already canceled. This is why it is imperative to have people you regularly talk with at the insurance firm you use. Ask your agent/service representative about climate risk language in your homeowners policy. If you feel that your policy does not effectively manage your climate risk exposure, then shop for a new insurance company before there is an issue.Suzanne Hollander, Esq.
Real Estate Law Professor at Florida International University’s Hollo School of Real EstateHow do you think climate change will impact homeowners insurance?
The impact of climate change (increased flooding, sea level rise, hurricanes, and other natural disasters) will lead to increased homeowners insurance premiums in locations prone to these types of natural events. On the other hand, homeowners insurance premiums may decrease in locations that are not prone to these types of events.Depending on the amounts of the increase, homeowners tolerance may be tested to an extreme, finally underlying a homeowner’s (or a commercial property owner’s) decision to vote with their feet and move to a location where insurance premiums and costs of living are lower. To combat property owners' flight caused by increased insurance rates, the local, state, and federal government may consider capping and limiting the percentage insurance companies may raise insurance premiums per year.What can homeowners concerned with weather threats do to make sure they’re covered?
Verify their policy. Read it. Make sure they have all the requirements for the area in which the property is located.What should homeowners do if their policy is canceled as the result of a weather emergency?
Immediately contact their lender. It may be a mortgage default if the homeowners insurance is canceled.We're firm believers in the Golden Rule, which is why editorial opinions are ours alone and have not been previously reviewed, approved, or endorsed by included advertisers. The Ascent does not cover all offers on the market. Editorial content from The Ascent is separate from The Motley Fool editorial content and is created by a different analyst team.